Why Insurance Companies Drop Coverage Due to Roof Age in Florida

For many homeowners in Melbourne, Florida, the phrase “roof inspection near me” is becoming a necessity more than just a routine maintenance request.

 Insurance policies are tightening rules, and in many cases, insurers may drop or refuse to renew coverage when a roof hits a certain age, typically around 15 years. Understanding why this happens and what you, as a homeowner, can do about it is crucial for protecting both your home and your insurance policy.

In this article, we’ll explain why insurance providers in Florida often drop coverage due to roof age, what the law requires, and how a well-documented Melbourne FL roof inspection can help you stay insured, negotiate with your insurer, or avoid surprises if you shop for a policy.

What’s Going On: The Rise of Roof Age Scrutiny?

The “15-Year Roof Rule” & Florida Statute 627.7011

  • Under Florida Statute 627.7011(5), insurance companies cannot refuse to issue or renew a homeowner’s policy solely because your roof is under 15 years old.
  • For roofs 15 years or older, insurers are allowed to require an inspection by an authorized inspector. If the roof is found to have at least five years of useful life remaining, there’s a higher chance the insurer will keep or renew coverage. If not, policy nonrenewal or requirement of replacement may follow.

Why Do Insurers Act This Way?

  • Risk & Liability: Older roofs are statistically more likely to suffer from leaks, structural wear, wind damage, and shingle loss, which are all common signs you need a new roof. In Florida’s demanding climate, these issues can escalate quickly, putting your home at greater risk for water intrusion and costly repairs.
  • Regulatory pressure & insurance market strain: Florida has seen rising insurance claims, litigation costs, and increasing risk exposure, pushing insurers to tighten underwriting rules.
  • Uniformity in coverage decisions: Even if a roof looks fine, insurers often use age as a proxy for risk unless an inspection proves otherwise.

What Homeowners in Melbourne, Florida Need to Know?

When Roof Age Triggers Coverage Risk

  • When your roof hits the 15-year mark, you may receive requests from your insurer:
    • Inspections (roof certification, “useful life” estimate)
    • Letters informing you of non-renewal risks if your roof doesn’t pass inspection. 
  • Some insurers have set upper limits for certain roof types like asphalt shingle vs tile vs metal. For example, while some allow 20-year use for shingles, many require inspections or limit coverage sooner. 

How a Melbourne, Florida Roof Inspection Helps You?

A well-conducted roof inspection, especially by a reputable local roofer, is one of your strongest tools for maintaining insurance. Here’s how:

What to Look for in the Roof Inspection?

  • Age of roof: date of last full replacement or span of current installed material
  • Material type: different materials age differently and are treated differently by insurers
  • Condition of key components: underlayment, flashing, ridges, valleys, gutters, vents, signs of moisture or rot
  • Evidence of prior repairs and whether they were done to code
  • Estimated remaining useful life

Documentation That Insurers Want

  • A detailed inspection report with photos clearly showing the condition of key elements
  • Signed statements from the inspector about the estimated remaining life
  • Dates of any repairs, replacement, maintenance, and invoices if available
  • Ideally, roof certification is required by the insurer

How Local Roofers Fit In?

  • Local roofers in Melbourne, Florida, best understand the coastal/Hurricane risk, Building Code requirements, and what insurers are looking for.
  • Choose roofers who are licensed, bonded, insured, and certified contractors.
  • Work with roofers who are experienced with insurance presentations. They can create inspection reports or certifications that meet insurer standards.

What Happens If You Don’t Take Action

  • Your insurance policy may be nonrenewed or dropped once the roof hits 15 years.
  • Switching to ACV or actual cash value coverage instead of replacement cost might happen, meaning you’ll only get a payout reduced by depreciation.
  • Premiums may increase, and deductibles might be higher for roof claims.
  • In worst cases, your home lender may force insurance, which is more expensive and less favorable.

Steps to Stay Covered & Protected

Here are actionable steps homeowners in Melbourne, FL can take:

  1. Schedule a Melbourne FL roof inspection well before the 15-year mark, especially if you bought the home recently and don’t know the roof’s history.
  2. Maintain records like invoices, photos of repairs, and maintenance. Keep them well organized.
  3. Work with the best local roofers to ensure inspections and repairs are done to code and documented professionally.
  4. Communicate with your insurer early. When the roof approaches 15 years, ask what their inspection or report requirements are, and whether they accept local roofer reports or require specific credentials.
  5. Consider upgrading roof materials or doing partial work if age is creeping up; sometimes replacement or reinforcement of vulnerable areas can buy more years.
  6. Review insurance policy terms, check age limits, clauses about roof age, whether the policy is ACV vs RCV or Replacement Cost Value, and what triggers non-renewal.

Common Misunderstandings

  • “My roof looks fine, there is no problem.” Appearance alone doesn’t always convince insurers. Underlying issues that aren’t visible can cost them money in a storm.
  • “Warranty covers me.” Manufacturer warranties usually cover defects in material, not age, weather exposure, or wear. Insurer concerns are actuarial more than warranty-based.
  • “It only applies to asphalt shingles.” Other materials are also reviewed for age and condition. Insurers may look at specific components like underlayment, waterproofing, and flashings.

What Homeowners Should Do in Melbourne Today?

  • If you see your roof is approaching 12-15 years, or you don’t know its age, search for “roof inspection near me” and get several quotes from reputable local roofers.
  • After the inspection, keep the report, photos, and follow up on any recommended minor repairs. Even small issues today can be avoided to prevent complications later.

Conclusion

Florida’s insurance market is changing, and one of the biggest levers affecting your homeowners’ insurance is the age of your roof. 

While roofs under 15 years are generally protected from non-renewal based solely on age, once you cross that threshold, insurers can require a detailed roof inspection and sufficient remaining roof life. 

As a homeowner, staying ahead by working with the best local roofers, documenting condition & repairs, and understanding your policy, can mean the difference between keeping coverage or losing it.

If you want protection, peace of mind, and to avoid surprise non-renewal, don’t wait until your roof is 15 years old. Contact Driftline Roofing today to schedule your inspection and ensure you’re meeting all insurer requirements.

Scroll to Top